Skip to content
Demo Polly
Contact Us

The average in-dealership auto insurance quote averaged around $200 per month throughout 2024, topping off at an average of $202 per month in Q4.

While this is good news, quotes are still creating price shock for many consumers, as it still represents an increase of more than $60 per month in the last two years. And quotes in higher cost states are 50% or more above the average 2024 rate, creating an affordability crisis for many car buyers and disrupting car sales for dealers.

Bar chart: average monthly insurance quote rising from $131 in Q3 2022 to $202 in Q4 2024

View the data behind this chart
Average monthly insurance quote, Q3 2022 to Q4 2024
QuarterAverage monthly quote
Q3 2022$131
Q4 2022$139
Q1 2023$140
Q2 2023$158
Q3 2023$182
Q4 2023$193
Q1 2024$195
Q2 2024$200
Q3 2024$199
Q4 2024$202

From Polly’s Q4 2024 Quarterly Embedded Auto Insurance Report.

Insurance Quotes Averaged $199 per Month in 2024.

This represents an 18% YOY increase from 2023, far outpacing the overall rate of inflation, and eclipsing changes in the consumer price index for new and used vehicles, which declined in 2024 by 0.4% and 3.3% respectively.*

$199 per month: 2024 average insurance quote

View the data behind this chart
Average monthly insurance quote, 2024
PeriodAverage monthly quote
2024 average$199

From Polly’s Q4 2024 Quarterly Embedded Auto Insurance Report.

Embedded Insurance Opportunity Continues to Improve

The embedded insurance opportunity for dealers in 2025 is excellent. The potential for dealerships to help alleviate consumer pain around insurance is high.

As rates have risen, consumers are shopping for insurance more than ever. Meanwhile, the market has become more competitive, with a greater number of insurance companies onboarding new business than in previous years.*

Embedded auto insurance opportunity rising from weak in Q4 2023 to near excellent in Q4 2024, with a map of opportunity by state

Back-End Gross Increased to 63% of the Total Gross Profit for Retail Auto Sales in Q4

Line chart: front-end gross falling from about $3,200 in Q1 2022 to about $1,000 in Q4 2024 while back-end gross holds near $1,900

In the last quarter of 2024, front-end gross dove towards $1,000, down 29% year over year.

This decline is driven by increased auto inventory* and declining affordability.**

However, back-end gross has remained constant for all of 2024, hovering within $55 of the average of $1,868 for the full year.

Donut chart: 63% of total profit is from back-end gross, 37% from front-end gross

*nada.org/nada/research-and-data/market-beat
**newsroom.aaa.com/2024/09/aaa-your-driving-costs-the-price-of-new-car-ownership-continues-to-climb/

View the data behind this chart
Share of total dealership profit from back-end and front-end gross, Q4 2024
Source of profitShare of total profit
Back-end gross63%
Front-end gross37%

From Polly’s Q4 2024 Quarterly Embedded Auto Insurance Report.

Insurance and Back-End Gross Improvement Across Top 10 Dealerships

In Q4, all our top ten most engaged dealer groups continued to see higher back-end gross with insurance, in line with the averages seen during the first three quarters of the year.

Fluctuation between groups is largely a function of average F&I penetration at each dealership.

Bar chart: average back-end gross per deal for 10 franchise dealer groups, with insurance quotes lifting back-end gross 18% overall and from 5% to 43% by group

Includes only High-Polly-Engagement dealerships (at least 50 quotes and quoting at least 2% of transactions) over the past 12 months.

View the data behind this chart
F&I gross lift with insurance quotes at 10 franchise dealer groups, Q4 2024
Dealer groupBack-end gross lift with insurance quotes
All+18%
Group 1+43%
Group 2+36%
Group 3+31%
Group 4+23%
Group 5+18%
Group 6+17%
Group 7+15%
Group 8+10%
Group 9+9%
Group 10+5%

From Polly’s Q4 2024 Quarterly Embedded Auto Insurance Report.

18% Higher F&I Gross Profit with Insurance Quotes

In Q4 2024, the average increase in back-end gross for dealerships that introduce their customers to Polly was 18%, for Q4 average lift of $331.

+18% higher F&I gross profit with insurance quotes

View the data behind this chart
F&I gross profit lift with insurance quotes, Q4 2024
MeasureValue
Higher F&I gross profit with insurance quotes+18%

From Polly’s Q4 2024 Quarterly Embedded Auto Insurance Report.

Predictions

The embedded insurance opportunity for dealers (positive effect of buying car insurance at the dealerships) has recovered to rates not seen since 2021, and will continue to improve in 2025.

States like New York, Maryland, and Georgia will remain outliers with high insurance rates due to regional risk factors, regulatory differences, and carrier pricing strategies. This will further drive demand for competitive, embedded insurance solutions at the dealership level.

With front-end gross shrinking due to inventory normalization and affordability challenges, dealers will increasingly rely on F&I products to maintain profitability. Expect more dealers to integrate embedded insurance solutions into their sales process to capture additional back-end revenue.

Start Growing with Polly

Let embedded auto insurance be your dealership's next growth tool.

Get Embedded